This word confusion post started with acts versus ask, and in the research, up came the controversial use of ax instead of ask in dialect. All three could be heterographs (a subset of homophone), as, depending on pronunciation, they could sound alike.
Ah’m Jes’ Axin’
It’s fascinating that ax is more legitimate than ask, lol, having been around for 1,200 years while ask has only been around for 900 years (Schultz). Schultz also points out that Chaucer used ax, and that it can be found in the Cloverdale Bible.
Ask has its own historical precedent in aks, which is a well-established feature of certain dialects and ast which is a phonetic spelling of a simple past tense and past participle of ask.
However legitimate ax, aks, or ast is as a way of making a request, the English language and culture is constantly evolving, and in this day and age, all three are considered poor English. Something to keep in mind when writing your character’s dialogue.
To Ax or Not to Axe
The alternative spelling of ax is axe, and they do mean the same (other than the request definition) and are common usage in America. Axe, however, is primarily British in this shared definition.
The version of axe that refers to musical instruments is slang from 1955 that initially referred to the saxophone, then to the trumpet, then to any tools a person used, then electric guitars, and, so far, most any musical instrument, except the drum. And yep, axe-man refers to a musician. Usually a guitar player.
Take Action!
Going back to acts, this plural for the noun and third person present verb is all about the action whether in a play or a performance, passing a law, behavior (including faking it!), fulfilling a function, or having an effect.
Exploring Later . . .
You may also want to have a look at “Act versus Action“.
Word Confusions . . .
. . . started as my way of dealing with a professional frustration with properly spelled words that were out of context in manuscripts I was editing as well as books I was reviewing. It evolved into a sharing of information with y’all. I’m hoping you’ll share with us words that have been a bête noire for you from either end.
If you found this post on “Acts vs Ask vs Ax(e)” interesting, consider subscribing to KD Did It, if you’d like to track this post for future updates.
Acts | Ask | Ax(e) |
---|---|---|
— |
— |
|
Part of Grammar: | ||
Plural for the noun and third person present verb for act
Abbreviation 1; Noun 2; Verb 2, intransitive & transitive Plural for the noun: acts Third person present verb: acts |
Noun 1, 2; Verb 1, intransitive & transitive, reporting Plural for the noun: ask Third person present verb: asks Slang variation: aks |
Noun 1, 3, 3; Verb 2, intransitive & transitive 1
Plural for the noun: axes third person present verb: axes Alternative spelling: axe |
Abbreviation: [Trademark] American College Test 1a Australian Capital Territory 1b Association of Classroom Teachers Noun:
[In singular noun] A pretense
A written ordinance of Congress or another legislative body
A main division of a play, ballet, or opera
The process of doing [Philosophy; in scholasticism] Activity in process
Verb, intransitive:
[With adverbial] Behave in the way specified
[act as] Fulfill the function or serve the purpose of
Take effect
Perform a fictional role in a play, movie, or television production
To be capable of being performed Verb, transitive:
To feign
To behave as [Obsolete] To actuate |
Noun: [US] A request, especially for a donation 1
[Scandinavian mythology] The first man, made by the gods from an ash tree 2 Verb, intransitive: [ask around] Talk to various people in order to find something out
Request (someone) to do or give something
Verb, transitive:
Invite (someone) to one’s home or a function
Verb, reporting: |
Noun: A tool typically used for chopping wood, usually a steel blade attached at a right angle to a wooden handle, used for felling trees, splitting timber, etc. 1
[Informal; US slang] A musical instrument, especially one played by a jazz or rock musician 3 Verb, intransitive: Verb, transitive:
Cut or strike with an axe, especially violently or destructively [West Indian or dialect; only as ax] Non-standard form of ask 2 |
Examples: | ||
Abbreviation: Many students are unable to take the ACT due to COVID-19. The ACT is a federal territory of Australia containing the Australian capital city of Canberra and some surrounding townships. ACT hosts virtual professional learning opportunities. Noun: They displayed many acts of heroism. Acts was written in Greek, presumably by St. Luke the Evangelist. She was putting on an act all day and laughing a lot. He did his Sir Galahad and Monty Python acts. Congress passed two acts that day. He attested to the act of witnessing the signing of his will. The Brown Act applies to legislative bodies of local agencies, including school districts. We’ve already seen the first and second acts. She has three set acts: her one-woman poetry act and her comedy routines about being a fat woman and a lifestyle coach. They booked two acts: the Apple Blossom Sisters and the Proud Ones. The boys were caught in the act. He performed a running act of checking to be sure that he was doing what he wanted to do (Chang). “If an essence has an act of being, the act of being is limited by that essence whose act it is” (Kerr). “It is the essence of the thing, standing in potency to a distinct act of existence, that accounts for the potentiality of creatures and thereby distinguishes them from God, who is not so composed” (Kerr). Verb, intransitive: Governments must act to reduce pollution. She always acts on his suggestion. It depends on one’s ability to act for community change. This attorney acts for him. She acts from greed. They followed the man who was seen acting suspiciously. He acts as if he owned the place. She acts well under all conditions. He acts like a civilized adult. They need volunteers to act as foster parents. We hope a five-year sentence will act as a deterrent. Bacteria acts on proteins and sugar. She acted in her first professional role at the age of six. He acts in three plays by Molière. She only acts dumb until she gets to know you. I am required to act before noon tomorrow. She acts like she’s his manager. The medicine acts as expected. Act interested even if you’re bored. His plays don’t act well. In my absence the assistant manager acts for me. Verb, transitive: She acts out other people’s jobs. The class was all about encouraging students to act out the stories. The impulses of hatred and killing which he acts out through his murders. She acts with all outraged virtue. He acts the fool. What caused him to act? |
Noun: It was an awkward ask for more funding. Those are the ask prices for those bonds. Askr and Embla were the first man and first woman, created from tree trunks found on the seashore by three gods — Odin and his two brothers, Vili and Ve (Editors). Verb, intransitive: The old man should ask about her job. There are fine meals to be had, if you ask around. Mrs. Savage asked after Iris’ mother. Don’t be afraid to ask for advice. When you arrive, ask for Catherine. Verb, transitive: Mary will ask her father for money. I will ask him to call the manager. She’ll ask if she could move in. Just wait and see. He should ask to see the officer involved. I’d ask $250 for the guitar. It’s asking a lot, but could you look through Billy’s things? It’s about time we asked Pam to dinner. Do you want to ask him along? A few boys asked her out but never the right ones. Verb, reporting: He asked if she wanted coffee. He asked whether his electric wheelchair would fit through their doors. |
Noun: I started swinging the axe at the lumps of driftwood. I was going to need a new ax blade. Thirty workers are facing the ax in the assembly department. She joined the board because she had an axe to grind with the school system. Check out my new axe, man. Verb, intransitive: The TV program was axed. Verb, transitive: Some 2,500 staff were axed as part of the realignment. The candidates all promised to axe government spending. The door had been axed by the firefighters. Don’t ax this question again. I axed him if he wanted some company. |
Derivatives: | ||
Adjective: actable, acting, actorish, actressy, unacted Adverb: actorly Noun: actability, actant, acting, actor, actress, postact Verb: misact, preact |
Adjective: unasking Adverb: unaskingly Noun: asker |
Noun: ax-man, axe-man, axmen, pickax, poleax |
Phrasal Verb | ||
acts out acts up |
ask about somebody ask around ask for somebody ask for something ask somebody back ask somebody in ask somebody out |
|
History of the Word: | ||
|
|
|
C’mon, get it out of your system, bitch, whine, moan . . . which words are your pet peeves? Also, please note that I try to be as accurate as I can, but mistakes happen or I miss something. Email me if you find errors, so I can fix them . . . and we’ll all benefit!
Satisfy your curiosity about other Word Confusions on its homepage or more generally explore the index of self-editing posts. You may also want to explore Book Layout & Formatting Ideas, Formatting Tips, Grammar Explanations, Linguistics, Publishing Tips, the Properly Punctuated, Writing Ideas and Resources, and Working Your Website.
Resources for Acts vs Ask vs Ax(e)
Some of these links may be affiliate links, and I will earn a small percentage, if you should buy it. It does not affect the price you pay.
Apple Dictionary.com
Cambridge Dictionary: ask
Chang, Hasok. “Operationalism.” Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. 17 Sept 2019. Web. 3 Oct 2020. <https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/operationalism/>.
Dictionary.com: act
The Editors of Encyclopædia Britannica. “Askr and Embla: Norse mythology.” Encyclopædia Britannica. 20 July 1998. Web. 3 Oct 2020. <https://www.britannica.com/topic/Askr-and-Embla>.
Jireis, Elias. “Why Guitar is Called Axe — Learn the True Origins of the Etymology.”” Novice Guitar. 9 Nov 2016. Web. 4 Oct 2020. <https://noviceguitar.com/why-guitar-is-called-axe-learn-the-true-origins-of-the-etymology>.
Kerr, Gaven. “Aquinas: Metaphysic.” Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy. n.d. Web. 3 Oct 2020. <https://iep.utm.edu/aq-meta/>.
McWhorter, John. “The ‘Ax’ versus ‘Ask’ Question.” LA Times. 19 Jan 2014. Web. 4 Oct 2020. <https://www.latimes.com/opinion/la-xpm-2014-jan-19-la-oe-mcwhorter-black-speech-ax-20140119-story.html>.
Morris, Evans. “Not, to Put It Mildly, Fair.” Word Detective. 10 April 2007. Web. 4 Oct 2020. p 3. <http://www.word-detective.com/041007C.html>.
Schultz, Colin. “People Have Been Saying ‘Ax’ Instead of ‘Ask’ for 1,200 Years: ‘Ax’ for ‘ask’ isn’t wrong, it’s just different.” SMARTNEWS. Smithsonian Magazine. 6 Feb 2014. Web. 4 Oct 2020. <https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/people-have-been-saying-ax-instead-ask-1200-years-180949663/>.
Tatman, Rachael. “Ask vs. Aks: Let me axe you a question.” Making Noise & Hearing Things. 12 Feb 2013. Web. 4 Oct 2020. <https://makingnoiseandhearingthings.com/2013/02/12/ask-vs-aks-let-me-axe-you-a-question/>.
Pinterest Photo Credits:
Parshuramsaraswats by Drshenoy is under the CC BY-SA 3.0 license at English Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Commons. It was transferred from en.wikipedia to Commons by Roland zh using CommonsHelper.
Revised as of 18 Oct 2022
By: Kathy Davie