Revised as of
3 Jan 2023
They do seem similar, don’t they? Nor do their definitions help us differentiate between the two, as both are about the real, the essentials.
Substantially, the substantial is more about a big thing, major, huge. Sizable. Considerable. Important. Something that has more of a physicality to it.
The substantive is more intellectual, especially when you consider the legal and grammar aspects of substantive! Although the physical crops up with that mordancy issue. Still, substantive is more about the quality of it, how meaningful it is, its independence, whether the most important or essential part of something will or has changed.
Word Confusions . . .
. . . started as my way of dealing with a professional frustration with properly spelled words that were out of context in manuscripts I was editing as well as books I was reviewing. It evolved into a sharing of information with y’all. I’m hoping you’ll share with us words that have been a bête noire for you from either end.
If you found this post on “Substantial versus Substantive” interesting, consider subscribing to KD Did It, if you’d like to track this post for future updates.
Substantial | Substantive |
---|---|
— |
— |
Part of Grammar: | |
Adjective; Noun
Plural for the noun: substantials |
Adjective; Noun
Plural for the noun: substantives |
Large, strong, important
Adjective: Of ample or considerable importance, size, amount, or worth
Of solid character or quality
Of real worth, value, or effect Concerning the essentials of something Of a corporeal or material nature
Basic or essential
Of or relating to the essence of a thing [Philosophy] Relating to or of the nature of substance or reality rather than an accident or attribute Noun:
[Usually used in plural noun] Anything large in amount or degree [Usually used in plural noun] Substantial or solid things [Usually used in plural noun] The substantial or solid parts of a meal |
Meaningful, essential, independent
Adjective: Having a firm basis in reality and therefore important, meaningful, or considerable
Real or actual Having a separate and independent function, resources, or existence Of considerable amount or quantity Possessing substance
[Law] Pertaining to the rules of right which courts are called on to apply, as distinguished from rules of procedure Solid in foundation or basis [Of a dye] Attaching directly to the material without the aid of a mordant [Grammar] Denoting, relating to, or standing in place of a noun Noun: A pronoun, adjective, or other word or phrase functioning as a noun |
Examples: | |
Adjective: It was a substantial amount of cash. There was a row of substantial Victorian villas that had fallen into disrepair. Now that was a most satisfying and substantial meal. The Brunstons were a substantial Devon family. There was substantial agreement on changing policies. You know that spirits are shadowy, human beings substantial, right? Peter had issues with minor aspects but was in agreement with the substantial parts of the ruling. John Henry had quite a substantial physique. Their two stories were in substantial agreement. There were substantial reasons for exercising eminent domain. Noun: Those who in the substantials of the Protestant Religion are of the same persuasions with our selves. “One who is certainly not chargeable with neglect of the substantials of historical science” (Pattison). “A great proportion of architectural ornaments are literally hollow, and a September gale would strip them off, like borrowed plumes, without injury to the substantials” (Thoreau, 41). “The substantials were all on a side-table” (Braddon). |
Adjective: There is no substantive evidence for the efficacy of these drugs. We need a more substantive adjective here. To be is a substantive verb. There are substantive issues under discussion. “Greer never recounts Crist actually governing or even engaging in any kind of substantive policy battles” (Wilson). Substantive law is a “statutory or written law that governs the rights and obligations of everyone within its jurisdiction” (Substantive). A substantive dye has a high affinity for cellulose fibers such as cotton or rayon, etc., even hair. Noun: I’ll have my regular, Erin. Where’s that sweetheart of mine? |
Derivatives: | |
Adjective: nonsubstantial, substantialism, substantialist Adverb: nonsubstantially, substantially Noun: substance, substantialism, substantialist, substantiality, substantialness Verb, transitive: substantialize |
Adjective: nonsubstantive, substantival Adverb: nonsubstantively, substantivally, substantively Noun: substance, substantiveness |
History of the Word: | |
Middle English from the Old French substantiel or the Christian Latin substantialis, is from substantia meaning being, essence. | Late Middle English, in the sense of having an independent existence, is from the Old French substantif + -ive or the late Latin substantivus, which is from substantia meaning essence. |
C’mon, get it out of your system, bitch, whine, moan . . . which words are your pet peeves? Also, please note that I try to be as accurate as I can, but mistakes happen or I miss something. Email me if you find errors, so I can fix them . . . and we’ll all benefit!
Satisfy your curiosity about other Word Confusions on its homepage or more generally explore the index of self-editing posts. You may also want to explore Book Layout & Formatting Ideas, Formatting Tips, Grammar Explanations, Linguistics, Publishing Tips, the Properly Punctuated, Writing Ideas and Resources, and Working Your Website.
Resources for Substantial versus Substantive
Some of these links may be affiliate links, and I will earn a small percentage, if you should buy it. It does not affect the price you pay.
Apple Dictionary.com
Braddon, M.E. One Thing Needful. Palala Press, 2015. <https://amzn.to/3e6fZwL>.
Dictionary.com: substantial, substantive
Oxford English Dictionary: substantial as a noun
Pattison, Mark. Pattison’s Essays. HardPress Publishing, 2014. Originally published 1889. I 8. <https://amzn.to/3SIULE4>.
“Substantive Law.” Legal Information Institute. Cornell Law School. Last updated May 2021. Web. n.d. <https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/substantive_law>.
Thoreau, Henry David. Walden, Or, Life in the Woods (1854). Les Prairies Numeriques, 2020. <https://amzn.to/3fEk8rT>.
Wilson, Rick. “The Messy, Sordid Story of Jim Greer, Charlie Crist’s Man to a Fault.”
The Daily Beast. 29 June 2014. Web. n.d. <https://www.thedailybeast.com/the-messy-sordid-story-of-jim-greer-charlie-crists-man-to-a-fault?source=dictionary>.
Pinterest Photo Credits:
Paris (50), 10 September 2016, Saturday, by Carl Campbell is under the CC BY-SA 2.0 license, via Flickr.